feature image for the smackdown blog: UGC vs Branded Content

Marketing Strategy Smackdown 🥊 UGC vs Branded Content

Gather around, it’s time to take our seats for the showdown. You’re sitting ringside, the crowd around you is buzzing with excitement, and the air is electric. Two titans are squaring off in the boxing ring, getting ready for an epic match. In one corner is company-crafted content, the heavyweight champion known for its power to narrate a compelling story. In the other corner is user generated content, the fast and flexible contender that’s winning hearts with its authenticity. Who will come out on top in the ultimate showdown of UGC vs branded content?

But, wait. This is not your typical boxing match. It’s a metaphorical battle between two powerful marketing strategies. Each of them has unique strengths, weaknesses, and the potential to pack a powerful punch for your brand. So, let’s dive into the ring and break down the fight round by round!

Understanding the contenders

Branded content is like the heavyweight champion. It’s crafted by the brand, polished to perfection, and packs the punch of a controlled message. It’s like a well-rehearsed play, where every act, every line is carefully choreographed to present the brand in the best light.

On the other hand, user generated content is the incredibly strong newcomer. It’s the breakout star—raw, authentic, and spontaneous. At times, it can be unpredictable. But it is always real, bringing the voices of customers to the stage, sharing their experiences, emotions, and opinions. User-generated content statistics show that customer content is the hands down favorite.

The strengths 👑

Content that’s thoughtfully created by the brand shines with its ability to tell a captivating story. It has the power to grab your audience by the collar and pull them into a narrative that resonates with them. The heavyweight champion uses this power to build a strong brand identity and foster a loyal following.

Audience-sourced material is nimble, able to quickly adapt and reflect the real-world experiences of your customers. It is genuine and relatable, which makes it a magnet for potential customers. It’s like a trusty review from a good friend, carrying a level of credibility that money can’t buy. It’s organic and has a knack for connecting with audiences on a deeper level. UGC has the knack for striking a chord with potential customers, thanks to its relatable and genuine nature.

The weaknesses 👊

Like any seasoned fighter, both our contenders have a few blind spots. Professional content, with all its polish and precision, can sometimes seem too salesy, too staged. It can be seen as self-promotion, which could make it less trusted by a cynical audience. You might be thinking about your overeager friend who can’t stop talking about their achievements. You appreciate and recognize the hard work, but it’s too much.

Consumer content is the people’s champion, but it’s not always perfect. It can be challenging to control and may stray from the brand message. Also, this contender is powerful but needs a careful hand to guide it. Also, not all user content is positive. A harsh review can send the brand reeling if not addressed effectively.


Now that you understand our competitors, buckle up, and let’s get ready!
We’re putting these giants head-to-head in five crucial rounds: authenticity, engagement, control, cost, and ROI.

Round 1: Authenticity

First off, let’s talk about who’s keeping it real.

In-house content might be the well-groomed champion, but it can sometimes come off as a little too polished, a tad too perfect. It’s like that beautiful wax apple in the store window—appealing, but can it be eaten?

Like a garden of freshly picked fruits, UGC programs offer a diverse array of content that may not always look flawlessly polished, but it’s bursting with realness and authenticity. This ripe and juicy material is like a delightful medley of flavors that resonates with audiences, making it a definite crowd-pleaser. In this round, the benefits of UGC shine bright as it confidently claims the trophy for winning hearts and connecting with potential customers on a deeper level.

🔍 60% of consumers believe UGC is the most authentic marketing content.

Round 2: Engagement

Next up is the all-important battle for audience engagement.

Company-crafted content steps into the ring with all the firepower of carefully crafted storytelling. It can weave a narrative that keeps audiences on the edge of their seats, but can it ignite a conversation?

Enter material from real consumers. It’s like having an open mic night where your customers are the stars. They share, they comment, they engage. It’s dynamic, it’s exciting, and it’s UGC claiming the victory in this round.

Round 3: Control

Now, let’s talk about who’s got the reins.

Business-authored material is like a well-trained horse, going exactly where the brand wants. The message, the tone, the image—it’s all under the brand’s control. The brand’s self-made content is the master of its destiny in this ring.

Audience-contributed content, though, is more like trying to herd cats. It’s unpredictable, hard to control, and can sometimes go off-script. So, in this round, the brand’s custom-made content takes the win!

Round 4: Cost

Time for the financial face-off.

In-house developed pieces, with its high production values and quality checks, can rack up a hefty bill. It’s like dining in a 5-star restaurant. Fabulous but pricey.

Consumer-created content is like a potluck dinner, where your customers bring their own dishes (content) to the table. It’s cost-effective and still a hit. The variety and eclectic nature is sure to please everyone. So, in the cost department, user content scores the point.

Round 5: ROI

Finally, the make-or-break round, ROI!

Brand-produced material, with its compelling narrative and polished presentation, can reel in a loyal audience and drive brand awareness. It’s an investment that can pay off handsomely over time.

Consumer-sourced content, meanwhile, capitalizes on its authenticity to create a bond with potential customers. It offers the double whammy of low cost and high impact, delivering a knockout punch in terms of ROI.

The final bell: branded content vs UGC

Well, folks, this match isn’t about declaring a clear winner or loser. It’s about understanding that these two giants each have their strengths. The true victory lies in leveraging them both strategically, creating a tag-team combo that delivers on all fronts: authenticity, engagement, control, cost, and ROI.

🔍 Brand engagements rise by 28% when consumers are exposed to a mixture of content from professional marketers and real customers.

Remember, it isn’t really about UGC vs branded content. The marketing ring is big enough for both. It’s all about striking the right balance and making them dance in harmony to the rhythm of your brand’s goals and values. So, let’s step out of the boxing ring and step into a winning marketing strategy!


Is UGC suitable for all types of businesses?
Absolutely! User generated content can benefit a wide range of businesses, regardless of their size or industry. It can humanize brands and establish trust among potential customers.

How can brands encourage customers to create content?
Brands can incentivize content creation through contests, giveaways, featuring user content, or implementing loyalty programs.

Is UGC more effective than traditional advertising?
User produced material tends to be more trusted and well-received than traditional advertising since it comes from real customers rather than the brand itself. So use content often hits harder than traditional ads.

Can UGC help with brand reputation management?
Yes! It can play a significant role in managing brand reputation. Brands can address negative aspects constructively, demonstrating their commitment to customer satisfaction.


  • linkdin
  • facebook
  • twitter